Indiana woman faces felony charges after trying to cash duplicate sportsbook ticket

A casino camera caught an Indiana woman trying to cash a sports betting ticket that was already paid out.

Written by the BettingEdgeHub desk, 2 October 2026

An Indiana woman is facing serious legal trouble following an incident at the Blue Chip Casino in Michigan City. Amanda Czarny allegedly tried to redeem a sports betting ticket worth one thousand three hundred ninety three dollars. Investigators stated that the payout for this specific ticket had already been collected by the original owner.

Surveillance footage reveals the truth

Security cameras inside the venue captured the entire sequence of events on the afternoon of September eighteenth. Footage showed the woman entering the sportsbook alongside the male bettor who actually owned the slip. After the rightful owner received his funds, the pair spent time together in the hotel lobby.

The second attempt goes wrong

Records indicate that the woman later returned to the sportsbook alone to collect money on the already settled ticket. Casino staff immediately flagged the suspicious transaction and notified the gaming commission agents on site. When confronted by authorities in the parking garage, she claimed the ticket was given to her voluntarily.

Legal consequences and additional charges

The male owner denied giving her the slip, and the security footage contradicted her explanation entirely. She now faces a Level six felony charge for cheating at gaming alongside a misdemeanor for possessing drug paraphernalia. Local law enforcement arrested her before she posted bond to secure her release from custody.

What it means for a bet

Always keep track of your physical betting tickets because sportsbooks have strict security measures to prevent duplicate payouts.

Carry on from here

Today’s betting tipsEvery price side by side, with the reasons against printed too.More betting newsEverything else we have written in this section.Bookmakers in United StatesOnly the ones that hold a licence where you are.The forumWhat other people are backing, and what they are avoiding.

18+. Gambling can be addictive, please play responsibly. This is a news page, not advice and not a tip. Nothing here is a promise about any result. Our calls live on the betting tips pages, with the reasons against them printed next to the reasons for them.